Hi, I recently released v1.6.0 of my app, bible feed, to f-droid. For some reason it has been tagged as NSFW and I notice this new metadata has been added to the top: AntiFeatures: NSFW: en-US: Promote ■■■■ and violence contents. https://gitlab.com/fdroid/fdroiddata/-/blob/master/metadata/com.me2christ.bible_feed.yml But this is a simple bible reader app that obviously does not promote ■■■■ or violence in any way. I did not add this metadata, so where did it come from and why has it been...
Probably does. That being said most fediverse and Wikipedia do not feature stories of young teens getting their father drunk to pass on the genes after seeing their mother turned to salt because some angels got lost in rapesville.
Wikipedia has literally anything you can imagine on it, so of course it does have that. Just the article about the bible itself probably contains all the fucked up things that appear in the bible.
And the fediverse has every kind of porn from incest to zoophilia on it.
I think the line is drawn if the content is contained in the app itself. Fediverse/Wiki apps are more like a browser. If you choose to visit a “NSFW” mastodon instance that is between you and the instance, not F-Droid.
If I read it correctly, they reverted the change for this app because it does not contain text itself.
It is fine to disagree about this for sure, in fact you’ll never find a solution that makes everyone happy. Fortunately, you can add other repositories to F-Droid if you don’t like there decisions.
Its kind of funny, but if thats the threshold for NSFW then basically any fediverse or wiki app on F-Droid needs to be marked as NSFW…
Maybe add an antifeature for “cult content” :D
Probably does. That being said most fediverse and Wikipedia do not feature stories of young teens getting their father drunk to pass on the genes after seeing their mother turned to salt because some angels got lost in rapesville.
Wikipedia has literally anything you can imagine on it, so of course it does have that. Just the article about the bible itself probably contains all the fucked up things that appear in the bible.
And the fediverse has every kind of porn from incest to zoophilia on it.
I think the line is drawn if the content is contained in the app itself. Fediverse/Wiki apps are more like a browser. If you choose to visit a “NSFW” mastodon instance that is between you and the instance, not F-Droid.
Thats a good point
The author of the app says, his app does not contain any bible texts. Only chapters.
I agree, many parts of the bible are not safe for work.
Downvote me for it, but I I think it should not be flagged. The bible is simply not covered by F-Droids NSFW definition.
If I read it correctly, they reverted the change for this app because it does not contain text itself.
It is fine to disagree about this for sure, in fact you’ll never find a solution that makes everyone happy. Fortunately, you can add other repositories to F-Droid if you don’t like there decisions.